Write notes on the following: (A) Concept of Public Interest Litigation (B) 74th Constitutional Amendment Act

by

Points to Remember:

  • Public Interest Litigation (PIL): A legal action initiated in a court of law for the enforcement of public interest or general interest. It’s a mechanism for addressing issues affecting a large segment of the population or the environment.
  • 74th Constitutional Amendment Act: An act that introduced the concept of urban local governments in India, aiming to empower them and improve urban governance.

Introduction:

This response addresses the concepts of Public Interest Litigation (PIL) and the 74th Constitutional Amendment Act of India. Both are crucial for ensuring good governance and citizen participation in a democratic society. PIL, a relatively recent development in Indian jurisprudence, has significantly broadened access to justice, particularly for marginalized groups. The 74th Amendment, on the other hand, aimed to revitalize urban governance by strengthening local self-government.

Body:

(A) Concept of Public Interest Litigation (PIL)

  • Definition and Origin: PIL is a legal action initiated in a court of law for the enforcement of public interest or general interest. It’s not limited to individual grievances but addresses broader societal issues like environmental protection, human rights violations, and consumer rights. Its roots lie in the recognition that traditional litigation mechanisms often fail to address systemic injustices affecting large populations. The Indian Supreme Court played a pivotal role in developing PIL jurisprudence.

  • Key Features:

    • Relaxed locus standi: Anyone can file a PIL, even without direct personal interest in the matter, as long as it’s in the public interest.
    • Wider range of issues: PILs encompass a wide range of issues, including environmental degradation, police brutality, corruption, and violation of fundamental rights.
    • Use of alternative methods: Courts may employ various methods like commissions of inquiry, amicus curiae (friend of the court), and suo moto cognizance (taking up a case on its own initiative) to address PIL issues.
    • Remedial measures: Courts can issue various orders, including injunctions, mandamus (court order compelling action), and directions to government agencies to rectify the situation.

  • Positive Impacts: PIL has been instrumental in bringing about positive social change in India. It has empowered marginalized communities, improved environmental protection, and held government accountable. Examples include cases related to environmental pollution, custodial deaths, and the rights of marginalized groups.

  • Challenges and Criticisms: PIL has faced criticism regarding frivolous litigation, misuse by vested interests, and the potential for judicial overreach. There are concerns about the burden on the judiciary and the need for efficient mechanisms to screen genuine PILs from those filed for ulterior motives.

(B) 74th Constitutional Amendment Act (1992)

  • Objective: The primary objective of the 74th Amendment was to strengthen urban local governments (ULGs) in India by providing them with constitutional status and greater autonomy. It aimed to improve urban governance, planning, and service delivery.

  • Key Provisions:

    • Constitutional status: The amendment added Part IX to the Constitution, dealing with ULGs, and the Eleventh Schedule listing 18 functions of municipalities.
    • Three-tier structure: It established a three-tier structure for urban local governance â?? municipalities, nagar panchayats, and municipal corporations, depending on population size.
    • State Election Commission: The amendment mandates the establishment of a State Election Commission to conduct elections to ULGs.
    • Finance Commission: It empowers the State Finance Commission to recommend the distribution of financial resources between the state government and ULGs.

  • Impact and Challenges: The 74th Amendment has had a mixed impact. While it has enhanced the constitutional status of ULGs and provided a framework for their functioning, implementation challenges remain. These include inadequate financial resources, lack of capacity building for elected representatives and officials, and political interference. Many ULGs still struggle with effective service delivery and financial autonomy.

Conclusion:

Both PIL and the 74th Amendment are vital instruments for achieving good governance and citizen participation. PIL has empowered citizens to hold the state accountable and address systemic injustices, while the 74th Amendment aimed to strengthen local self-governance. However, both mechanisms face challenges. To enhance their effectiveness, there is a need for stricter guidelines for PILs to prevent misuse, improved capacity building for ULGs, and greater financial autonomy for local governments. A holistic approach focusing on transparency, accountability, and citizen participation is crucial for achieving sustainable development and upholding constitutional values. Strengthening these mechanisms is essential for building a more just and equitable society.

JPSC Notes brings Prelims and Mains programs for JPSC Prelims and JPSC Mains Exam preparation. Various Programs initiated by JPSC Notes are as follows:- For any doubt, Just leave us a Chat or Fill us a querry––