Do you agree that the philosophy behind the Preamble of the Indian Constitution is under threat in the present scenario? Explain with suitable examples.

by

Keywords: Preamble, Indian Constitution, philosophy, threat, present scenario.

Required Approach: Analytical (with elements of opinion based on factual analysis).

Points to Remember:

  • Core values of the Preamble: Sovereignty, Socialism, Secularism, Democracy, Republic, Justice, Liberty, Equality, Fraternity.
  • Threats to these values: Rising intolerance, social inequalities, political polarization, erosion of institutional integrity.
  • Examples of threats: Specific instances of violence, discrimination, and policy decisions.
  • Potential solutions: Strengthening institutions, promoting inclusive policies, fostering social harmony.

Introduction:

The Preamble to the Indian Constitution serves as a concise statement of its fundamental objectives and guiding principles. It proclaims India to be a “Sovereign, Socialist, Secular, Democratic, Republic” ensuring justice, liberty, equality, and fraternity to all its citizens. However, in the present scenario, several challenges threaten the very philosophy enshrined within this foundational document. Whether these threats constitute a genuine “undermining” is a matter of ongoing debate and requires careful analysis.

Body:

1. Threats to Secularism:

The Preamble’s commitment to secularism, ensuring equal rights to all religions, faces challenges from rising religious intolerance and polarization. Instances of communal violence, hate speech, and discriminatory practices against religious minorities raise concerns about the erosion of this fundamental principle. While the Constitution guarantees religious freedom, the practical implementation faces hurdles. For example, the rise of majoritarian narratives and instances of targeted violence against religious minorities demonstrate a clear threat to the secular fabric of the nation.

2. Threats to Social Justice:

The Preamble’s promise of social justice, liberty, equality, and fraternity is challenged by persistent social inequalities based on caste, class, gender, and religion. Despite constitutional provisions and affirmative action policies, deep-rooted discrimination continues to marginalize significant sections of the population. The persistence of caste-based violence, gender inequality, and economic disparities highlight the ongoing struggle to achieve the social justice envisioned by the Preamble. Reports from the National Crime Records Bureau on crimes against Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, for instance, reveal the grim reality.

3. Threats to Democracy:

The democratic ethos of the Preamble is threatened by factors such as political polarization, erosion of institutional integrity, and declining faith in democratic processes. The increasing influence of money and power in politics, coupled with instances of political violence and intimidation, undermine the principles of free and fair elections. Concerns about the independence of judiciary and other institutions further exacerbate this threat. Examples include instances of political interference in the functioning of independent bodies and the weakening of checks and balances within the governance system.

4. Threats to Liberty:

While the Preamble guarantees liberty, concerns exist regarding restrictions on freedom of expression, assembly, and association. The use of laws like sedition and the increasing surveillance of citizens raise questions about the extent of individual liberties in practice. The chilling effect on dissent and critical voices can be seen as a gradual erosion of the fundamental right to freedom.

5. Threats to Sovereignty:

While less directly challenged, India’s sovereignty can be indirectly threatened by external pressures and internal divisions. The need to balance national interests with global engagement requires careful navigation. Internal divisions, if left unaddressed, can weaken the nation’s unity and its ability to assert its sovereignty effectively.

Conclusion:

The philosophy behind the Preamble of the Indian Constitution is undoubtedly facing significant challenges in the present scenario. The threats to secularism, social justice, democracy, liberty, and even indirectly to sovereignty, are evident through various social, political, and economic indicators. However, it is crucial to avoid a pessimistic outlook. The Constitution itself provides mechanisms to address these challenges. A way forward involves strengthening democratic institutions, promoting inclusive policies that address social inequalities, fostering interfaith harmony, and ensuring the rule of law prevails. By actively upholding constitutional values and engaging in constructive dialogue, India can strive towards realizing the ideals enshrined in its Preamble, ensuring a future where justice, liberty, equality, and fraternity are not merely aspirational goals but lived realities for all its citizens. This requires a collective commitment to constitutionalism and a continuous effort to build a more just and equitable society.

JPSC Notes brings Prelims and Mains programs for JPSC Prelims and JPSC Mains Exam preparation. Various Programs initiated by JPSC Notes are as follows:- For any doubt, Just leave us a Chat or Fill us a querry––