Why was Birsa Munda released from prison on 30th November 1897 before the expiry of his sentence? (A) His health condition was bad (B) Diamond jubilee celebration of Empress Victoria (C) Popular pressure on the government (D) Mercy petition filed by Christian missionaries on his behalf

Points to Remember:

Birsa Munda’s imprisonment and release.
Reasons for his premature release.
Historical context of late 19th-century India.
Analysis of potential reasons for release.

Introduction:

Birsa Munda (c. 1875 â?? 1900) was a tribal freedom fighter and religious leader who played a significant role in the resistance against British colonial rule in the region of present-day Jharkhand, India. He was arrested multiple times for his activities, which were perceived as a threat to British authority. His release from prison on November 30th, 1897, before the completion of his sentence, remains a subject of historical debate. This question requires a factual and analytical approach to evaluate the potential reasons provided. We will examine the plausibility of each option provided, considering the historical context and available evidence.

Body:

A. His health condition was bad: While Birsa Munda undoubtedly faced harsh conditions in prison, there is limited concrete evidence to suggest his health was so severely deteriorated that it necessitated his immediate release. Prison records from that era are often incomplete or inaccessible, making it difficult to definitively confirm or deny this claim. Without detailed medical records or contemporary accounts specifically mentioning a critical health crisis, this reason remains speculative.

B. Diamond Jubilee celebration of Empress Victoria: The Diamond Jubilee of Queen Victoria’s reign in 1897 was a significant event in British India. The British government often used such occasions for gestures of goodwill and clemency. However, there is no direct evidence linking Birsa Munda’s release to this celebration. While it’s plausible the government might have used the occasion for political expediency, it’s crucial to note that such releases were usually granted to political prisoners of higher profile or those deemed less dangerous. The lack of documented evidence linking this specific event to Munda’s release weakens this possibility.

C. Popular pressure on the government: Birsa Munda had garnered significant support among the tribal population. His religious and political activism had created a considerable following, and his imprisonment likely fueled resentment towards the British administration. Popular pressure, expressed through protests, petitions, or even unrest, could have influenced the government’s decision. However, the extent of this pressure and its direct impact on the release decision require further investigation. While

11.4-132.3 11.4-132.3s0-89.4-11.4-132.3zm-317.5 213.5V175.2l142.7 81.2-142.7 81.2z"/> Subscribe on YouTube

D. Mercy petition filed by Christian missionaries on his behalf: Some accounts suggest that Christian missionaries, who had interacted with Birsa Munda, might have intervened on his behalf. However, this claim needs substantiation. The motivations of such intervention would be complex and require careful analysis. Did the missionaries genuinely believe in his cause, or were they acting out of strategic considerations to maintain a degree of control over the tribal population? The absence of documented evidence of such a petition makes this a less likely explanation.

While several reasons for Birsa Munda’s premature release from prison on November 30th, 1897, have been suggested, none are definitively supported by strong historical evidence. The lack of comprehensive documentation from that era makes it challenging to pinpoint the exact reason. It is possible that a combination of factors, including perhaps some level of popular pressure and a calculated decision by the British administration to mitigate potential unrest, contributed to his release. Further research into colonial records and oral histories is needed to shed more light on this event. A holistic approach to understanding this historical event requires acknowledging the limitations of available evidence and the complexities of colonial power dynamics. Future research should focus on accessing and analyzing relevant archival materials to provide a more complete and accurate understanding of this significant moment in Birsa Munda’s life and the history of tribal resistance in India.