Local Governance and Autonomy in Scheduled Areas of Jharkhand

Jharkhand, a state in eastern India, is home to a large tribal population that resides in its Scheduled Areas, as defined under the Fifth Schedule of the Indian Constitution. These areas, which are predominantly inhabited by various indigenous tribal communities, have historically faced issues related to governance, autonomy, and political representation. The state's constitutional provisions, particularly with respect to local governance and autonomy, are crucial in ensuring the cultural and political rights of the tribal population. This article delves into the local governance structures in Jharkhand's Scheduled Areas, examining the legal frameworks, challenges, and implications for tribal communities.

The Scheduled Areas and Tribal Identity

Scheduled Areas are regions in India where the tribal population is either in the majority or has a significant presence. The Constitution of India recognizes these areas in order to protect the rights and welfare of tribals, who often face marginalization and exploitation. In Jharkhand, districts like Ranchi, Dumka, and Khunti are classified as Scheduled Areas.
The indigenous tribes of Jharkhand, including the Santhal, Munda, Oraon, and Ho, maintain a distinct cultural and social identity. These tribes are traditionally linked to the land and its resources, and their governance has often been based on customary laws and practices.

Constitutional Framework for Local Governance

The Indian Constitution provides specific provisions under the Fifth Schedule that apply to Scheduled Areas. These provisions were designed to safeguard the socio-economic rights of tribal populations and ensure their participation in governance. The provisions primarily focus on local governance, autonomy, and the regulation of land and natural resources.
The Fifth Schedule of the Constitution:

The Fifth Schedule pertains to the administration of Scheduled Areas and the protection of tribal rights. It empowers state governments to enact laws that allow tribals to manage their resources and participate in governance.

The Schedule also outlines the establishment of the Tribal Advisory Council (TAC), which is tasked with advising the state on matters related to the welfare and advancement of tribals.

Provisions for Local Governance:

Local governance in Scheduled Areas of Jharkhand is governed by the Panchayats (Extension to Scheduled Areas) Act, 1996 (PESA Act). The PESA Act is a significant step toward decentralizing governance and empowering tribal communities.

Under the PESA Act, Panchayats in Scheduled Areas are given more authority over local affairs, particularly in relation to land, natural resources, and cultural practices.

Panchayats (Extension to Scheduled Areas) Act, 1996 (PESA Act)

The PESA Act, a landmark legislation, extends the provisions of the 73rd Amendment to the Constitution to Scheduled Areas. It aims to strengthen local self-governance by recognizing the authority of tribal communities over their lands and resources. The PESA Act provides several critical features:
Empowerment of Gram Sabhas: The Gram Sabha (village assembly) is given the authority to make decisions on key issues like land acquisition, local resource management, and the regulation of customary practices. It ensures that the decision-making power is vested in the hands of the local community rather than external authorities.
Autonomy in Resource Management: The PESA Act grants local tribal communities the autonomy to manage their natural resources, including forests, water, and minerals. This is particularly significant in Jharkhand, where the tribal population is heavily dependent on forest and land resources for their livelihood.
Tribal Advisory Council (TAC): The Act also mandates the creation of a Tribal Advisory Council in states with Scheduled Areas. The council advises the state government on matters related to the welfare and development of the tribal population, ensuring that tribal rights are safeguarded in policy-making processes.
Customary Laws and Practices: The PESA Act recognizes the importance of customary laws and practices in tribal governance. These laws often govern local customs, dispute resolution, and land use, offering a layer of legal protection to tribal traditions.

Autonomous District Councils (ADC)

In addition to the PESA Act, Jharkhand also has Autonomous District Councils (ADC), a system that offers greater autonomy to tribal communities in certain districts. The concept of ADCs is part of the states commitment to empowering tribals through decentralized governance.
Formation of ADCs: The ADCs are established under the provisions of the Sixth Schedule of the Constitution, which allows for the creation of autonomous councils in regions with a substantial tribal population. These councils have the authority to make decisions regarding local development, land, and natural resources within their jurisdiction.
Powers and Functions: The ADCs in Jharkhand have the power to make laws on a variety of subjects, including land alienation, forest management, and traditional customs. This enables tribal communities to exercise greater control over their territories and reduce external interference from non-tribal elements.
Examples of ADCs: In Jharkhand, the Santal Pargana Autonomous District Council and the Chotanagpur Autonomous District Council are examples of such institutions, designed to ensure that the tribal population has a say in the governance of their regions.

Challenges to Local Governance and Autonomy

Despite the legal frameworks in place to ensure autonomy for tribal communities in Jharkhand, several challenges hinder the effective implementation of local governance systems:
Lack of Awareness and Capacity: Many tribal communities, particularly in remote areas, lack awareness of their rights under the PESA Act and other relevant laws. This lack of knowledge undermines their ability to actively participate in governance and decision-making processes.
Bureaucratic Interference: While the PESA Act and ADCs are intended to empower local communities, bureaucratic interference at the state and district levels often undermines the autonomy of these bodies. Local governance institutions frequently face resistance from state and district authorities who may not fully appreciate the importance of decentralized governance.
Land Alienation and Resource Exploitation: One of the most significant threats to tribal autonomy is the continued alienation of tribal land, often for mining and industrial projects. The push for economic development, coupled with weak enforcement of land protection laws, has led to the displacement of tribal communities.
Political Instability: The tribal areas of Jharkhand have often been subject to political instability, which affects governance. Frequent changes in leadership and conflicting political interests can disrupt the continuity and effectiveness of local governance structures.
Underdevelopment: Despite the provisions for autonomy, many areas in Jharkhand continue to face underdevelopment. The lack of infrastructure, poor education systems, and limited access to healthcare services further marginalize tribal populations.

Role of Civil Society and NGOs

Non-governmental organizations (NGOs) and civil society groups play a crucial role in advocating for the rights of tribal communities in Jharkhand. These organizations help raise awareness about the PESA Act, assist in the capacity building of local leaders, and provide legal support to fight land alienation cases. They also work to ensure that the tribal populations rights are recognized in policy-making processes at both the state and national levels.

JPSC Notes brings Prelims and Mains programs for JPSC Prelims and JPSC Mains Exam preparation. Various Programs initiated by JPSC Notes are as follows:- For any doubt, Just leave us a Chat or Fill us a querry––